Company History

Agency Background

The Seibert Insurance Agency, a full-service, one-stop agency representing more than 100 top insurance companies, has been servicing the Tampa Bay area’s insurance needs since 1971. Our team of 13 professionals provides life, personal or commercial automobile, professional liability, homeowners, rental, dwelling fire, business owners policies, commercial property or general liability insurance for almost 7,000 individuals and families and more than 500 businesses.

Headquartered at 5121 Ehrlich Road in Tampa, Seibert Insurance is one of the most fully automated independent agencies in the area, with a state-of-the-art computer system to ensure that we deliver superior customer service. We also serve our customers with innovative programs such as our Teen Driving Program taught by agency staff and using real life examples.

Seibert Insurance also is a leader in addressing important industry issues such as staged-accident fraud. We are among the founding members Fraud Alert Team of Tampa Bay, an active supporter of the Florida Association of Insurance Agents and the National Insurance Crime Bureau.

The agency is equally committed to supporting our local community through membership and sponsorship in numerous organizations.

President and Founder

V. Keith Seibert Founder

Keith Seibert founded the agency in 1971, and incorporated it as an independent agency in 2008. A graduate of Youngstown State University, he began his insurance career in Tampa as an agent with Nationwide Insurance Company as a personal lines agent. He was then recruited into Nationwide’s business insurance program, National Accounts, where he worked with national companies to write their multi-state stores/operations. In 1981 Mr. Seibert was the Nationwide Business Agent of the Year, and from 1988-1993 was in the top 10 commercial producers of the company.

He continues to build relationships with commercial clients in the agency.

Karyn Seibert Roeling  President & Owner

Day-to-day operations of Seibert Insurance are managed by Karyn Seibert Roeling. After graduating from Florida State University in 2002 with a degree in Risk Management and Insurance (which is ranked one of the top 10 programs in the US), she joined USAA Insurance Company as a Property and Casualty Underwriter and soon advanced to a management role as a Lead Underwriter. In 2005, Mrs. Roeling decided to join the family business where she quickly rose through the ranks, received her Chartered Property Casualty Underwriter designation (CPCU) in 2007, and was named vice president in 2008 and president in 2012.

Mrs. Roeling has also taken leadership roles in several of the industry’s professional associations, as a Director of Professional Insurance Agents Florida, a founding member of Fraud Alert Team Tampa Bay and a Future Florida Insurance Leader with Florida Association of Insurance Agents.

She is also a leadership team member for BNI, the world’s largest referral organization, and has personally participated in community organizations such as the March of Dimes, Cystic Fibrosis, “Lock up” for MDA, Paint Your Heart Out Tampa Bay (I organized a team to paint a home in Tampa) and was a restaurant recruiter for The Best Taste of Tampa Bay (raises funds for TBPAC).