Leadership
Karyn Seibert Roeling
PRESIDENT
Candice Brantley
COO
Natalie Moore
OPERATIONS ANALYST
Commercial Insurance
Maria Shaw
COMMERCIAL INSURANCE CONSULTANT
Hunter Blair
COMMERCIAL INSURANCE CONSULTANT
Debbie Santana
COMMERCIAL SERVICE TEAM LEAD
Tina Russell
SENIOR COMMERCIAL ACCOUNT EXECUTIVE
Laura Chiarito
COMMERCIAL ACCOUNT MANAGER
Nicole Gagliardo
COMMERCIAL ACCOUNT MANAGER
Will Jachens
COMMERCIAL ACCOUNT MANAGER
Personal Insurance
Jennifer Hagemeyer
PERSONAL INSURANCE CONSULTANT
Anthony Vidal
PERSONAL INSURANCE CONSULTANT
Holly Koch
PERSONAL SERVICE TEAM LEAD
Anastacia Koch
PERSONAL ACCOUNT MANAGER
Taryn McGrory
PERSONAL ACCOUNT MANAGER
Kaylie Koch
PERSONAL ACCOUNT MANAGER
Cory Hodgerson
PERSONAL INTAKE SPECIALIST
Agency Support
Brandi Sarrett
BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT MANAGER
Carlee Vessel
ADMINISTRATIVE ASSISTANT
Kim Rolf
ACCOUNTING SUPPORT
Via Oro
SUPPORT TEAM LEAD
Kat Quinto
COMMERCIAL SUPPORT SPECIALIST
Wally Ignacio
PERSONAL SERVICE SUPPORT SPECIALIST
Mario Del Poso
PERSONAL SALES SUPPORT SPECIALIST
Bob Soriano
LEAD RECEPTIONIST
Our History
Keith Seibert graduated Youngstown State University and started his insurance career at Nationwide Insurance as a personal insurance agent. He went on to be recruited by Nationwide’s business insurance program.
About SIA
Seibert Insurance Agency prides itself on exceptional customer service and uses innovative technology to provide service and support to the agency’s clients.
At Seibert Insurance, we work with a wide range of insurance carriers to provide coverage solutions for individuals and businesses alike. Whether you need commercial general liability insurance, commercial property insurance, or builders risk insurance in Florida, our team is here to help.
We also specialize in home and auto insurance, offering independent policies that fit your unique needs. Looking for specialized coverage? We provide personal watercraft insurance and more to ensure you’re protected. As a trusted independent agency, we compare policies from top-rated carriers to find the competitive coverage at great rates. Let us help you safeguard what matters most!
Expert Help From Expert Insurance Agents
We’ve built our reputation in Tampa by going the extra mile for our clients. If you have questions about your insurance or you’re looking to get a better policy, please contact us today!